| Site Information | |||||||||||
| Site Title: | Harry Potter & The Hero's Journey, Star Wars | ||||||||||
| Site Domain: | harrypotterwars.ytmnd.com | ||||||||||
| Created by: | daniyelgarcia | ||||||||||
| Created on: | 2005-08-12 12:00:04 | ||||||||||
| Image Origin: | uncited | ||||||||||
| Sound Origin: | uncited | ||||||||||
| Preview: |
|
||||||||||
| Description: | Harry Potter follows the Hero's Journey | ||||||||||
| Keywords: | |||||||||||
| Site Stats: | |||||||||||
| Rating: |
|
||||||||||
| Total Votes: | 972 | ||||||||||
| Site Views |
|
||||||||||
| Your rating: | Log in to vote (75 users have this site on their favorites list) | ||||||||||
| Report this site | |||||||||||
| Site Sponsorship: | Sponsor this site! (Click here for more info) | ||||||||||
| No donations for this site. | |||||||||||
| Add a comment: | |||||||||||
| Comments: |
| FIFEN! | ||||||
| lol harry potter is recycle Star Wars | ||||||
| LOL it's the same. | ||||||
| interesting | ||||||
| harry skywalker | ||||||
| 5'd | ||||||
| Her0wned | ||||||
| So true. | ||||||
| Wow...never realized that | ||||||
| Well done. | ||||||
| That's really good. | ||||||
| should be: 'the Sorcerer's Stone'. the Philosophers Stone relates to FMA. good stuff though. | ||||||
| o snap | ||||||
| wow nice !!!
Very intelgient^^ | ||||||
| I can't not give this a 5, but change Philosopher's to Sorcerers. | ||||||
| Philospoher is what teh english say. English wrote the book. Philosopher is prefered :D | ||||||
| win | ||||||
| and philosopher's is original, from england, sorcerror's is american | ||||||
| TOO BAD ALL THE INFORMATION IS COMPLETELY FALSE. LITERALLY, NOTHING ON HERE HAPPENS IN HARRY POTTER. |
-3 | |||||
| HEHEHEHEHEHEHHEHE | ||||||
| SWEET | ||||||
| Philosopher is what attention whores use | ||||||
| 5'd for John Williams. He pwns. | ||||||
| Yay for franchises ripping off other franchises. XD | ||||||
| good good | ||||||
| Nice! Good job. Wow, cage is still here? what a stupid fanboy. | ||||||
| Good concept. Five for you. | ||||||
| Hmmm... I'll five this for the John Williams bit at the bottom. JOHN WILLIAMS FTW. | ||||||
| never noticed that. 5ify'd! | ||||||
| I knew there was more than one reason that i hated JK rowling! | ||||||
| True story. | ||||||
| Wow. | ||||||
| Han Solo = Ron? WTF! | ||||||
| not front page material | ||||||
| The comparison are all lame, AND I've seen this before. | ||||||
| I saw this, like, years ago. It's barely amusing, if at all. Definitely not front page material. | ||||||
| so f*cking true. | ||||||
| u win | ||||||
| Downvotes wish they had excuses. | ||||||
| hahah the john williams comment made it a 5. | ||||||
| Why do downvoters make sh*tty ytmnd's? | ||||||
| WIN WIN WIN WIN | ||||||
| WIN!
5! | ||||||
| LMAO
LOLOL | ||||||
| Winnar! | ||||||
| so that's how JK rolling came up with harry potter....she a big stgar wars nerd!!! | ||||||
| That all oddly falls in place:D | ||||||
| f*ck yes, for studying hero's journey in class. | ||||||
| Lord voldemort = Harry's dad? | ||||||
| Brilliant! 5/5 | ||||||
| I wouldn't be surprised if in Book 7 Voldermort turns out to be Harry's father. | ||||||
| Voldermort: Hagrid never told
you what happened to your father.
Harry: He told me enough! He told me you killed him.
Voldermort: No, I am your father. | ||||||
| HAHAHA | ||||||
| Well, five for the hero's journey/joseph campbell reference. | ||||||
| These downvoters are morons. This is quality sh*t right here. 5'd | ||||||
| Nice... | ||||||
| Ahaha, that's great. | ||||||
| Um...so? Yes, different stories follow the same models, and the models themselves have been in place for thousands of years. Did you just now figure that out? | ||||||
| No, Cronos. There is more lore Philospher's Stone than in that stupid anime. Not to mention the fact that it was the "Sorcerer" Stone's ORIGINAL title. | ||||||
| "All this will be set to a score by John Williams" XDXDXD | ||||||
| Wow, Jett, you are so smart! See how the guy that made this didn't realize "The Hero's Journey?" Wow good looking out dipsh*t! | ||||||
| Oh yeah, look at me: I post things cause I think I know more than everyone. It's just a funny ytmnd! YTMNDs have been around for thousands of years, did you just figure that out now? | ||||||
| This is beyond stupid. The sentences are so vague and impertinent that you could fit any two stories together with that much generality. Hagrid's distinguishing feature is his beard? give me a break. | ||||||
| Oh man Ninjayadda is a genius! He knows more than the internet! | ||||||
| If the entire population of the internet were "here", they would probably agree with me. | ||||||
| Oh man, I think EVERYTHING on here is unoriginal. I have not seen one idea here that supposedly someone had first. *BTW- what I just said is copyright. | ||||||
| Cronos, you f*cking wap. You know that the Philospher's stone was not created for f*cking Full Metal Alchemist, right? Please tell me you do.
The original title was Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone. Tards. | ||||||
| Hey exqva, do me a favor. Take a moment and think, long and hard, about how many times, in the history of mankind, someone has wrote a plot for something. | ||||||
| Now I want you to think even harder, but don't hurt yourself, ok? Think about how mathematically improbable it is that someone can write a completely original story, that has no similarities to any other story, at all. Think you can do that? | ||||||
| -1 for "Wilderness of Suburbia." -1 for "WISE, bearded Hagrid." -1 for "Hogwart's." -1 for "Darth Vader, whom we know murdered his aunt and uncle." -30,000 for omitting every single unique concept in each work and then acting like it's an am | ||||||
| -azing discovery when the two turn out similar. I'll just give you the benefit of the doubt and round up to a 1. | ||||||
| all who downvote this are harry potter nerds and will remain virgins for life. that is all | ||||||
| What does that make you then, Mr. Star Wars and Harry Potter fan? | ||||||
| all the people who downvote this because there are details missing are idiots. it obviosly says synopsis | ||||||
| its comedy. get over it you uptight f*cks. | ||||||
| Man, look at everything everywhere, everything follows the Hero's Journey. I learned about it 5 minutes ago by looking it up on dogpile. Harry Potter is original, Star Wars is unoriginal. The bible and Jesus is a ripoff of Star Wars too. I know more than | ||||||
| everyone cause I do good Google searches. /end sarcasm | ||||||
| Wow this guy reference's "Hero's Journey." Yet you all complain about how everything copies everything blah blah blah. It's a funny YTMND. Harry Potter music, stupid pic. THat's what we're here for | ||||||
| it's true.... it's true!!! | ||||||
| XD OWNED. | ||||||
| really f*ckin ironic.. | ||||||
| voltron1 speaks the truth. downvoters are really, really overthinking this. | ||||||
| oh, forgot to rate it. right on! | ||||||
| I agree with the downvoters who are saying that mythical tales do have similar elements so the people who are saying potter was copied from star wars are f*cking idiots. But the YTMND is still fairly original and funny so it gets a 5. | ||||||
| I like all the dipsh*ts saying "omg she ripped off starwars!". Did you not read the aprt about the HERO'S JOURNEY? Have you f*cking heard of JOSEPH f*ckING CAMPELL? Props to exvqa for not being retarded. | ||||||
| LOL! | ||||||
| O.o Never knew. | ||||||
| Nice. 5ed. | ||||||
| HAHA | ||||||
| Older than dirt, but still funny. | ||||||
| So? | ||||||
| ddddaaaannnniiiiyyyyeeeellllggggaaaarrrrcccciiiiaaaa is the sh*t... oooohhhh yyyyeeeeaaaahhhh!! | ||||||
| Use the magic, Harry! | ||||||
| pwned! | ||||||
| OWNED!@!!!!! | ||||||
| OMFGGGGGGGGGGGG | ||||||
| i loled my penis off | ||||||
| That is the most amazing thing I've ever read in my entire live ever. | ||||||
| good, better, this! | ||||||
| Kind of funny. I assume that Cronos is just being a troll, but I'll repeat that the Philosopher's Stone from the first HP and FMA are based on the same myth. It was only Sorcerer's Stone in one country. | ||||||
| Everything nowadays follows the heroes journy.. So i'm not surprised. | ||||||
| Nothing nowadays is original.. So I'm not surprised. | ||||||
| wow, nice, very nice | ||||||
| omgwtf? whats next? Snape is Hary's Father???? lololol | ||||||
| This anaylsis is recycled from Dead Ringers.
Ripping off something to showcase the ripping off of something.
I do not appreciate the irony.
1'd | ||||||
| This anaylsis is recycled from Dead Ringers. Ripping off something to showcase the ripping off
of something. I do not appreciate the irony. 1'd Now excuse while I put on my glasses and fake cape |
+1 | |||||
| I knew it.. | ||||||
| but lukes i mean harrys parents arent darth vader | ||||||
| dude thats pretty funny i never thought of that...thats pretty lame actually what a ho bag jk rowlings is... why did we like her books as 8-year olds? | ||||||
| Harry Potter ripped off Star Wars! NOOOOOOOOO YOU BITCH! | ||||||
| Actually, the book is called "HP and the Philosopher's Stone" in England. Star Wars has its uneditted versions, CSS has CS 1.6, and Harry Potter has the British version. It's just the way the major fans like it.
Very nice comparison. | ||||||
| lol | ||||||
| Badass. | ||||||
| Harsh, yet SO VERY TRUE. I LOVE how the final line remains untouched! | ||||||
| Too much discussion, not enough 3's, which is what this YTMND is. | ||||||
| Hahaha... never noticed that before... | ||||||
| lol at people overanalyzing this ytmnd...5'd | ||||||
| Awesometastic. | ||||||
| ROFLMAO HAHAHAHHAH THAT IS HILARIOUS! btw, the Philosipher's stone is the Sorceror's stone: British version. | ||||||
| Cage is a freaking donwvoter, look at his profile he downvotes pretty much everything except for Nazi sites and Religion sites! UPVOTE FOR GREAT JUSTICE!! | ||||||
| Lol steal! | ||||||
| hahaha, reading Harry Potter (the books) and watching Stars Wars (the original trilogy) have been some of the best pleasures in my life | ||||||
| nice call (John Campbell much?) | ||||||
| *Joeseph Campbell | ||||||
| 5 Even though Star Wars is a recycle of any typical fantasy. Lucas even admitted it.... before he went off the deep end and made ewoks and Jar Jar.... | ||||||
| lol, it's friggin true, awseome | ||||||
| Felt too "set up". The whole thing at the last half tried too much to connect the plots together, mostly because the whole dqueditch was only part of the story, while it's the forces of evil which is the other and the Star Wars plot is just 1 straight thing. | ||||||
| made me lol | ||||||
| |||||||
| LAWLLLLLLLLLLLLLL | ||||||
| Five for you clever intellectual comparsion of the two and showing what's really going on here. But it's the socerors stone.. | ||||||
| 5 for harry potter ripping off star wars. Star Wars > Harry Potter. | ||||||
| HOLY sh*t. | ||||||
| I KNEW IT SOUNDED FAMILIAR! | ||||||
| HAHAHAHAHAHAHA | ||||||
| All of this will be set to an orchestral score by John Williams. | ||||||
| YOU WIN! GOOD DAY SIR! | ||||||
| Almost there. Aunt and Uncle do not equal Parents, otherwise this would be a 100% perfect fit! It's still awesome, though. | ||||||
| I thought there was some study saying there are 32 basic story themes. This nails the 2 plots to a T. | ||||||
| Harry Potter ripped off Star Wars...sad. | ||||||
| I saw this a long time ago. I wonder why it took so long to make it to YTMND. | ||||||
| Brilliant. | ||||||
| Snape kills Obi-Wan. | ||||||
| |||||||
| very nice | ||||||
| John Williams makes the ytmnd great. :D | ||||||
| Oh snap..... Someone bring that bitch up on Copyright Infringement. | ||||||
| I saw this on YTMND a long time ago. I wonder why it took so long to make it to recent NARV activity.
. | ||||||
| Cage, everything in there happens to potter...Star Wars ftw, and nice ytmnd!! | ||||||
| 5d for pissing off the harry potter nerds. pwnt! | ||||||
| LOL | ||||||
| LOL this is great.
bit the only problem I see is that Vader didn't kill the uncle and aunt. she suicide bombed herself and owen when the stormtroopers showed up for a domestic dispute. | ||||||
| F*ck Harry Potter, if he was a real man he would have got in the sack with Hermione ages ago.
| ||||||
| OMG WTF that is so goddamn..strange...f*cking five. | ||||||
| Hero's Journey... Formula + Characters = Compelling Story. Cite sources please. | ||||||
| I love starwars. No wonder i like harry potter too :p ITS ALL THE SAME! | ||||||
| Amazing how this concept can be applied to so many things. Still, 5. | ||||||
| You win. Snape still kills Dumbledore. If only he had the resolve to off everyone else. | ||||||
| Funny, I was just thinking of that while watching Star Wars today. | ||||||
| the similarities are not that great, you crossed off a lot of detail there. You basically equated darth's death star to lord voldemort's quittage match among other far reaching lines. | ||||||
| O RLY? | ||||||
| YA RLY! | ||||||
| Ttly | ||||||
| Seen it li3k... A Bajillion years ago. | ||||||
| Owned. Stupid welfare moms getting rich with gibberish writing and stupid teachers. | ||||||
| 5'd for the last sentance | ||||||
| Eragon is worse, but Harry Potter is still bad. | ||||||
| lol @ cronos, you're why they changed the title to Sorcerer's stone in the US. | ||||||
| Wow. That was a nice catch! | ||||||
| I just finished helping my friend write a paper on the Hero's Journey Monomyth using Star Wars as the main focus/example, 5 for relevance to my life | ||||||
| 5'd for hero's journey. You're the learned man now dog. | ||||||
| hero's journey lol my personal favorite step is the Return with the Elixir | ||||||
| HO! | ||||||
| 3'd for obviousness | ||||||
| Most stories about a protagonist fit this same mold. | ||||||
| I'd tap that. Maybe not from the front, but I'd tap that all the same. | ||||||
| omg never noticed that | ||||||
| F*CKiNG LOL! | ||||||
| Lol, John Williams. This site owns! | ||||||
| how did you find that out!:) | ||||||
| 5 for bashing Harry Potter Nerds! | ||||||
| F*ck harry potter. | ||||||
| lmao best part is how the part about John Williams is exactly the same. | ||||||
| winwinwin | ||||||
| I like how the last line is untouched. | ||||||
| There are only about 10 different plots and they were all done in Greek plays 2000+ years ago | ||||||
