The photoshopping "skillz" could be a lot better, but I like the concept for its originality. The pic is basically a large image of some bagels, most of it is not needed, and then there is a b&w image poorly cropped out. Make it look like he is coming out of the bagel or something, blend the images better, and work on the size ratio of the two. You don't want to confusing image to detract from the joke, since your site is quite good conceptually.