I forgot to score it. Gave it a 5, cause it made me think.

Meh

It all depends on your point of view. You can believe that Garfield is not dead, and that this was all just a nightmare. Otherwise, you can believe that he is living the rest of his life in the abandoned house, denying that he is alone by using his imagination, while he is actually starving to death. So yeah, you be the judge.